Water Heater Installation & Replacement in Madison, WI

Three Generations of Plumbing Experience

Of all of the appliances in your home, your water heater may be the one you depend on the most. Your water heater supplies you with clean, dependable hot water on demand, and a surprising number of fixtures depend on this in your home when you think about it. 

So when something goes wrong with your water heater, it’s easy to become stressed and annoyed at how much of an impact it can have on your life. When you need your water heater replaced, our dependable Madison, WI plumbers can outfit your home with a brand new, state-of-the-art system that’s perfectly fitted to your home and your needs.

In need of water heater replacement in Madison? Receive a free estimate by contacting Arndt & Son Plumbing today! Proudly serving Brooklyn, WI & the surrounding areas.

Arndt & Son Plumbing has provided quality plumbing services for three generations, and in that time we’ve learned what it means to be the best at what we do. We’re proud to be the premiere plumbing service provider in the Madison area, and we’ve gotten there through years of hard work, exceptional craftsmanship, and customer service which is truly geared towards what you and your home need. 

We prioritize your satisfaction in every job we take, and that means delivering a quality product, installed correctly the first time, and doing so while offering service which simply isn’t matched by anyone else. We want to earn your business every day, both for today and every day going forward, meaning we want to be the last plumbing company you ever have to call again.

When you choose our team for your water heater needs, you benefit from::

• Three generations of experience applying practical knowledge to both older homes and new construction in and around Madison
• Fully licensed and insured plumbers who understand current plumbing, gas, and mechanical codes
• Respectful in-home service with shoe covers, protective rugs, and thorough cleanup after the job
• Clear, upfront pricing so you can make informed decisions before any work begins

When you invite us into your home for water heater work, you benefit from three generations of plumbing knowledge applied to today’s codes and technology. Our family-owned team understands how Wisconsin’s freezing winters and local building standards impact venting, drainage, and equipment selection, so we take the time to recommend options that fit both your hot water needs and your type of home in the greater Madison area.

Signs You Need a New Hot Water Heater

One of the most common questions we receive from customers who are experiencing problems with their water heater is whether or not they need to replace their heater, or if they can simply repair it and keep it going a while longer. 

While each case is unique, there’s one easy-to-follow rule—if your tank is leaking, you need to replace it. It’s extremely difficult to repair a leaking tank, and usually not cost-effective either. 

Additional signs you may need water heater replacement include:

• Hot water that isn't lasting as long as it used to
• Water that isn't getting hot at all
• Strange noises coming from your water heater
• Rusty water coming out of your faucets
• Water that smells and tastes metallic 
• Your water heater frequently needs repairs
• Your water heater is getting older

Many homeowners are unsure how urgent these warning signs are, especially if the unit is still producing some hot water. In our experience serving homes across Madison and nearby communities, changes in water color, odor, or noise often point to internal corrosion or sediment buildup that will only get worse over time. If you are noticing a combination of these issues, we can help you evaluate whether a proactive water heater installation in Madison makes more sense than continually putting money into an aging system.

How Long Do Hot Water Heaters Last?

The average tank will generally last about eight years, so if your tank is starting to approach this age, you may want to consider replacing it soon.

Actual lifespan can vary based on water quality, usage patterns, and how well the water heater was installed in the first place. Hard water, which is common in many parts of Wisconsin, can speed up sediment buildup and shorten how long a tank-style heater remains reliable. During an appointment, we can take a look at the condition of your equipment, review past repair history, and talk through whether a straightforward water heater replacement in Madison is the most practical long-term choice for your household or business.

Extend Your Water Heater Lifespan with Corro-Protec

At Arndt & Son Plumbing, we offer top-notch solutions for your water heater. Stop hot water tank corrosion with Corro-Protec powered anode rods! With a 20-year warranty, these anode rods provide superior protection, significantly extending your water heater's lifespan. Enjoy reduced maintenance costs and improved efficiency by choosing Corro-Protec. Contact us to get yours installed!

Corro-Protec is especially helpful in areas with harder water or older plumbing, where traditional sacrificial anode rods can wear out quickly. By upgrading to a powered anode, many homeowners see fewer odor issues, less rust in the tank, and more consistent performance over time. When we visit your Madison property, we can explain how this upgrade fits with your current system and whether pairing it with a new water heater installation could give you the best balance of performance and protection.

How to Choose the Best Water Heater for Your Needs

Here are some things you should keep in mind when choosing a new water heater:

• How much water do you use?
• How big of a space do you have for your water heater tank?
• How concerned are you about your current energy consumption?
• How big are your existing gas and water lines?

Beyond these basic questions, it also helps to think about whether a standard tank, high-efficiency model, or tankless system fits the way your family actually uses hot water. For example, larger households or homes with luxury showers may benefit from higher recovery rates, while smaller homes or condos in the Madison area might prioritize compact units that free up floor space. During a visit, we can review options, explain how each type performs in our local climate, and help you feel confident about the water heater installation choice you make.

Types Of Water Heaters We Install And Replace

Choosing the right type of unit is just as important as deciding when to replace your current water heater. Different homes, buildings, and usage patterns in the Madison area call for different solutions, and we work with you to match equipment to your daily routines. We can discuss how your family uses hot water, how long you plan to stay in your home, and what matters most to you in terms of upfront cost, operating cost, and available space.

For many homeowners, a traditional tank-style gas or electric water heater remains a dependable, budget-friendly choice that works well with existing venting and fuel lines. Others may be interested in high-efficiency or hybrid models that can reduce energy consumption over time, especially in our cold winters when systems work harder. We also work with tankless systems that provide continuous hot water when sized and installed correctly, which can be a good fit for certain layouts and lifestyles.

Some common water heater options we can review with you include::

• Standard tank heaters that offer reliable performance and familiar operation
• High-efficiency units designed to help lower energy use over the life of the system
• Tankless water heaters that heat water on demand and can save space
• Gas or electric configurations selected to match your existing utilities and local code

Because Madison and nearby communities follow Wisconsin plumbing and mechanical codes, it is important to choose equipment that can be properly vented and installed for our climate. We take care to review manufacturer requirements, local regulations, and your home’s current setup before recommending specific models. That way, your water heater installation in Madison is planned around both your comfort and the way your home or business is built.

Expert Water Heater Replacement in Madison, WI

Arndt & Son Plumbing wants your experience with us to be first-rate in every aspect. We not only offer upfront and transparent pricing, but we make sure that every aspect of our visit is up to our high standards of quality as well. We arrive on-time and respond quickly to your calls, and we treat your home with the respect it deserves. We always make sure to wear shoe covers and use protective rugs to keep our work area clean.

When you call us for water heater work, you get a fully licensed and insured team that understands the safety considerations involved with gas, electric, and venting connections. We work carefully to follow applicable codes for Dane County and surrounding municipalities, test the system before we leave, and walk you through basic operation so you know what to expect from your new unit. Our goal is to make water heater replacement Madison homeowners can rely on for dependable hot water and a smooth, low-stress installation day.

Call Arndt & Son Plumbing at (608) 530-1301 or contact us online today if you need a new water heater and let us provide you with a quality installation service!